The City of Portland Permitting and Development Office wrote a scorching report on PGE’s controversial proposal to expand electrical lines in Forest Park and recommended denying approval due to non-compliance with environmental standards. Staff said the plan’s mitigation was inadequate for the significant negative environmental impacts it would create. At the January hearing they also cited the failure of PGE to adequately consider alternative routes.

PGE’s proposal would remove nearly 5 acres of trees including some highly valued Oregon oak. It would replace existing trees with shrubs and pollinator habitat that would be maintained by PGE for five years. The company also committed to invasive plant removal and improving PGE road leading to the area.

A number of organizations, including city agencies, and individuals vigorously opposed the proposal and testified at the hearing. Representatives of Forest Park Conservancy, Bird Alliance of Oregon, the Sierra Club, Mazamas, Portland Parks & Recreation, the West Multnomah Soil & Water Conservation District, and the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife opposed the project.
They cited issues including: the area to be cleared is Northern red-legged frog habitat. It is listed as a sensitive species in Oregon; the proposal contradicts the top priority of the Forest Park Natural Resources Management Plan to manage the forest towards old growth; there has not been enough information disclosed about future phases of the 5-phase project which would clear more trees, among other issues.
Representatives of PGE say the project is needed because electricity use has grown.
The decision will next be reviewed by a hearings officer, where PGE can present their case. If the hearings officer upholds the city’s recommendation, PGE will have the option to appeal the decision.


