Closing arguments in the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) trial challenging the $24.6 billion merger of grocery giants Kroger and Albertsons, parent companies of Fred Meyer and Safeway, were heard on September 17 in Portland’s federal courthouse. Judge Adrienne Nelson will decide whether to grant the FTC’s request for an injunction. It could be several weeks before the decision is announced.
If Judge Nelson grants the injunction, it would prevent Kroger and Albertsons from closing their deal until the FTC’s internal court reviews the case. In practice, however, most companies abandon merger plans following an injunction.
Attorneys General of the states of Arizona, California, the District of Columbia, Illinois, Maryland, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon and Wyoming all joined the FTC’s lawsuit to block the deal. Washington state and Colorado state filed separate cases in state courts seeking to block the merger. Washington’s case opened in Seattle on September 16.


Revelations from the trial: Walmart is not the main competitor
Kroger and Albertsons say that a merger will allow them to be more efficient and cut prices by giving them greater bargaining power with suppliers. Kroger has promised to invest $1 billion to lower prices.
The FTC argues that decreased competition will give Kroger more power to raise prices, especially in areas such as North Portland where it currently competes with Albertsons-Safeway. The agency presented evidence that Kroger and Albertsons view each other as primary competitors.
Kroger claims it needs to acquire Albertsons to compete with Walmart. However, internal communications suggest that Kroger does not lower prices to match Walmart’s even when it can. A witness from the American Economic Liberties Project, research manager, Laurel Kilgour, detailed an example in which Kroger executives knew they could price their milk 10 cents below Walmart. Instead, they held prices at 10 cents above Walmart for at least a month. In another instance, Kroger maintained egg prices even when both Walmart and wholesale prices dropped and prices at a neighboring Albertsons store did not. The Kroger store only lowered egg prices when Albertsons lowered theirs, suggesting that competition with Albertsons, not Walmart, influences Kroger’s pricing most.
Selling to C&S won’t create competition
Kroger has offered to sell off 579 stores to C&S Wholesale Grocers if the merger goes through in order to create competition. But an expert witness, marketing professor, Edward Fox, noted that Kroger and Albertsons aren’t selling C&S the distribution centers necessary for the stores to succeed.
Fox said that roughly half of the sold stores would lose their primary distribution center. C&S can support some stores with its existing distribution network, but Fox said that in key markets, C&S’s distribution assets are “not sufficient…to support those stores.” Fox testified that stores will also lose key tech assets that support e-commerce and loyalty programs, such as pricing algorithms and data analytics.
Fewer store brand labels with C&S
Kroger and Albertsons own a network of food processing plants that make some of their store brand products. Consumers are buying more store brand products to manage rising food prices. Yet Kroger and Albertsons plan to sell C&S just one of their food processing plants, a dairy facility in Colorado. C&S would pick up five of Albertsons’s store label brands, but Fox argued that “C&S will clearly be challenged to replace the private label sales.”
Meanwhile, Kroger is suing the FTC alleging that the agency’s internal court review violates the Constitution. If the Supreme Court rules against the FTC, it could change how the federal government enforces anti-trust laws.
Stay tuned to the North Peninsula Review for breaking news on the merger decision through our mid-month subscribers’ newsletter, the Peninsula Pulse, and our social media.
(some information sourced from FoodandPower.net)

