Eagles Ohio headquarters shuts down North Portland Lodge

Share this

The 54-year-old North Portland Eagles Lodge at 7611 N. Exeter was shut down suddenly and unexpectedly by the national governing body of the Fraternal Order of Eagles, the Grand Aerie, on Friday, November 15. The locks were changed while members were still in the building. All scheduled events at the Lodge are canceled due to the closure.

During the COVID pandemic, the national headquarters sent the local lodge a letter of non-compliance citing board officers who were not fulfilling their duties. In July, the Grand Aerie placed North Portland Lodge #3426 in receivership. Their agent, Mike Simonds, was sent to help the lodge become compliant with the Order’s bylaws and meet financial goals. Simonds told members he was not there to shut down their charter.

Local members worked to achieve compliance by tripling their membership to more than 170, increasing their operating cashflow beyond requirements, and completing all required paperwork. New young recruits such as Marey Ryan were actively engaged in improvements. The lodge achieved full compliance within just three months, and according to lodge president David Foster, the North Portland Lodge #3426 was recognized by the Order as the #1 New Leader Club in the nation two months ago.

North Portland Eagles Lodge members from left:
Marey Ryan, Eagles friend Rick Scheetz from the Veterans of Foreign Wars, Tom Machen, Cliff Schrock the Worthy Chaplain, Nancy Smith lodge secretary, and Bill Kingsley a 40-year member.

But on October 8, Simonds forced a vote of members to either disband or downsize and move from the current building on 7611 N. Exeter, saying members would be given time to find a new building. Some said they were reluctant to vote, but Simonds said if they did not vote he could act as proxy and vote in their place. All the members present voted to downsize rather than disband.

The Worthy Chaplain of the North Portland Lodge, Cliff Schrock recalled, “We had a good meeting on Thursday, Nov. 14. Financials looked good, and we had three new members.” Workers hired by Eagles headquarters in Ohio arrived without warning the following day and changed the locks. “No notice. No documentation. No nothing!” said Schrock. Regional headquarters in Seattle confirmed the closure. The sudden move has shocked, saddened and angered many local members.

When asked for a comment by the North Peninsula Review, the Eagles governing body said a statement will be issued to the media later.

On Sunday, Nov. 17, a Grand Aerie representative opened the doors of the building and allowed members to retrieve their belongings. The North Peninsula Review spoke with several Lodge members on site. Said Bill Kingsley, a 40-year member, “I’ve been trying to contact the Grand Aerie for three weeks with no response.” Another member, Tom Machen, was concerned about contracts for scheduled events. “We had twenty contracts that are now null and void. The wrestling event owners are out of a lot of money.” 

The lodge secretary, Nancy Smith, said she was not notified of the closure by a directive as required in the bylaws. She added, “We worked so hard to get to compliance and had just started getting back to doing charitable work. We were going to hold a Thanksgiving dinner for 100 and request donations for the St. Johns Food Share.”

The N. Exeter Eagles Lodge property consists of a 20,000-square-foot building and a 1¼-acre parking lot currently valued at $4-5 million. The governing body has assumed ownership of the property as well as the SE Hawthorne Eagles’ Lodge building, which belonged to the North Portland Lodge. The Grand Aerie also has access to the lodge’s bank accounts.

The N. Exeter building has been a popular, affordable community events center for over 50 years and has played a substantial role in the North Portland community as a meeting place for the Eagles, the Veterans of Foreign Wars (VFW), Alcoholics Anonymous, and other community organizations. It has hosted a popular Sunday Swap Meet for many years, as well as fundraisers, pro wrestling, dances, auctions, weddings, celebrations of life, and quinceañeras, a traditional coming-of-age celebration for Hispanic girls. 

Police arrive after altercation
Eagles Lodge members called police after Grand Aerie agent, Mike Simonds, got into a physical altercation with Flea Market vendor, Ken Geller and others on Nov. 24.
The North Peninsula Review has filed a police report request.

TIMELINE: THE SHUTDOWN OF EAGLES LODGE #3426

July 24, 2024 – The Eagles governing body in Ohio, the Grand Aerie, places the North Portland Lodge in receivership. Their agent, Mike Simonds, tells the local Lodge he’s there to help them reach compliance with bylaws and will not close the Charter. He gives them financial goals.

Aug, Sept, Oct. 2024 – Eagles #3426 members complete paperwork, increase operating cashflow and triple their membership to achieve compliance within just 3 mos.

September 2024 – The club was recognized by the Eagles governing body as the #1 New Leader Club in the Nation.

October 8, 2024 – Simonds forces a vote to either downsize or surrender the charter and disband. All members present voted to downsize rather than disband. Simonds says lodge members will be given time to find a new building. 

November 12, 2024 – Eagles #3426 Secretary Nancy Smith visits the Order’s national website to add 3 new members’ names. She sees that the names of North Portland Eagles’ members have disappeared from the national website.

November 13, 2024 – Smith is locked out of the national website. She calls the Ohio office for help and they tell her she must contact agent Simonds.

November 14, 2024 – Lodge #3426 holds a regular meeting. Finances are healthy and three new members are added.

November 15, 2024 – Workers hired by the Eagles governing body arrive to change locks on the building. Members are still inside.

Mid-November, 2024 – A letter dated Oct. 13 is sent to lodge members from National headquarters stating that Lodge #3426 is pending dissolution 5 days after they’ve voted to downsize rather than dissolve.

November 17, 2024 – Members are allowed inside the building to retrieve their belongings; they occupy the building for several hours. The Grand Aerie representative calls police to have the members arrested for trespassing. Police do not arrive. 

‘November 24, 2024 – Flea Market vendors arrive who are not aware of the change. They are accustomed to go inside the building to use the restroom. Grand Aerie agent Simonds tells vendor, Ken Geller, he cannot enter. An altercation ensues. Simonds admits to police that he pushed Geller.