By Barbara Quinn
A snapshot of the tense dynamic between the North Portland Eagles lodge and the national Eagles unfolded in a court hearing at the Justice Center on Sept. 11 when the two nonprofits met before Judge Jeffrey Auxier.
Prior to the skirmish, the Grand Aerie of the Fraternal Order of Eagles, its governing body, requested a preliminary injunction to shut down all activities at the lodge at 7611 N Exeter and have it vacated before a final decision is made on building ownership at a February 2027 court hearing.
To get a court-ordered injunction, the Grand Aerie must prove they have been irreparably harmed by current activities there. The building and its 1.25 acre parking lot in question are estimated to be worth around $5 million currently.
North Portland lodge #3426, represented by its president, St. Johns resident Clifford Schrock, and its lawyers, responded to the injunction request with their own suit stating that North Portland Eagles members purchased the lodge with their own funds and still own the title which they have continuously held for 36 years.

The recent standoff began in fall of 2024 when the governing organization sent their agent, Mike Simonds, known as the “closer,” to help bring the 56-year old North Portland lodge into compliance with bylaws. See Eagles headquarters shuts down North Portland Lodge at NorthPeninsulaReview.com.
Local members worked to achieve compliance by tripling their membership to more than 170, increasing their operating cash flow beyond requirements, and completing all required paperwork.
Nonetheless Simonds forced a vote to either disband or downsize and move. Many members were reluctant to vote for either, but Simonds said he could act as their proxy and vote for them if they did not. The members reluctantly voted to move. The group was given six months to consider what to do next.
But one month later, Simonds canceled all the memberships and on Nov. 15, 2024, he changed the locks on the building when members were still inside. He immediately started to stage the contents for a sale and clean out all the files. To stop this, in January 2025 local members had the Simonds’ locks removed and regained control of the building and contents.
The request for an injunction by Simonds and the national Eagles states that the North Portland Eagles are not in compliance with “internal remedies available under the Fraternal Order governing document and instead resorted to self-help by retaking possession of the property without authorization.”
In the court hearing, on Sept. 11, Simonds, who admitted on the stand that he was a paid agent for the national Eagles, said the request to vacate the building was due to complaints about noise, parking and trash left over from an event. He also admitted that his role as a receiver is to “work for the sole benefit of the [local] aerie.”
The judge said, “Seeing trash on the property once is not irreparable harm. There is substantial question about ownership of the property. The defendant [Simonds and the national Eagles] failed to meet their burden of proof.”
The decision allows North Portland Eagles to keep their lodge for now. A major court hearing in February 2027 will decide its final ownership and the North Portland Eagles’ future. Stay tuned to the North Peninsula Review for updates. τ

