Opinion: Three pools—two different outcomes

Share this

By Mary Ann Aschenbrenner, Friends of Pier Park (Edited for space by Mark Kirchmeier)

Portland talks a lot about equity and inclusion, but those values are clearly not extended to poorer communities in North Portland. Just examine what has happened to the Columbia Park, Pier Park and Grant Park swimming pools, representing three different Portland neighborhoods, to see how the city spends resources in already privileged communities.

Columbia Park Pool is in the Portsmouth neighborhood, the poorest neighborhood in the City of Portland with the highest poverty rate and lowest median household income. Portsmouth rivals adjoining St. Johns in the high number of children eligible for Portland Parks swim lessons. Portsmouth also has more African American residents and St. Johns more Hispanic/Latino residents in comparison to theGrant Park neighborhood. In addition, Grant Park, a wealthier neighborhood, has far fewer children than either Portsmouth or St. Johns. 

Comparison of child population in each neighborhood

In 2014, voters approved a Parks Replacement Bond to repair and maintain infrastructure in Portland’s aging parks facilities. Yet Columbia and Pier Pools did not receive any of those funds. Grant Park Pool did.

Columbia Park Pool before closure in 2020
Columbia Park Pool before closure in 2020

Columbia Pool had been a year-round pool since 1975. It became a favorite for water aerobics classes, swim team practice and high school swim meets. It also offered swim lessons, a year-round swim team, and winter-time exercise for lap swimmers. Yet the Park Bureau did not maintain Columbia Park Pool,forcing its closure in 2020.

Pier Park Pool is located in an economically struggling and diverse section of the St. Johns neighborhood. It is just north and adjacent to Portsmouth and similarly did not receive Parks Replacement Bond funding. Pier Pool is truly a community pool with parents waiting on the deck while their children take swim lessons, or participate in swim team; adults enjoy lap swimming; and youths enjoy swimming and playing. On the free-swim days, children line up around the block to get in. Yet Pier Pool has been under-maintained for decades. Its main water pump was pulled from a World War II Victory Ship 80 years ago. Parks closed Pier Pool for the summer 2024 season because that water pump system failed.

Pier Park Pool. Photo from Portland Parks & Recreation
Pier Park Pool. Photo from Portland Parks & Recreation.

The Grant Park Pool is located more centrally in Portland and in a more affluent neighborhood. The 2014 Replacement Bond funded an overhaul of the outdoor pool’s mechanical system including replacement of plumbing, pumps, motors, pipes, chemical controllers, sanitation systems, gutters, deck drains and filters. The upgrade made many ADA improvements including repair of cross slope issues and installation of two new pool lifts with straps. Like Pier Pool, Grant Pool was originally powered with a vintage Victory ship pump. However, it has the good fortune of being located in the affluent Grant Park neighborhood and the city renovated the pool in 2016.

The youth and community members in St. Johns, Portsmouth and most of North Portland have been left without access to pools as summer cooling centers and without the opportunity to learn how to swim in an area surrounded by rivers.

We are calling on the City of Portland to fund maintenance of our existing North Portland pool systems to serve our more diverse communities and better live up to its stated goal of equity.

Portland swimming pools' maintenance backlog