U.S. District Court Judge Karin J. Immergut declared on Saturday that the Trump administration had failed to show cause for their planned deployment of Oregon National Guard soldiers to Portland.
Immergut, whom Trump appointed in 2019, ruled that the president improperly took control of 200 state National Guard troops and ordered him to return them to state control under Gov. Tina Kotek.
The judge asked U.S. Justice Department attorneys in a Friday hearing why Trump’s official order to federalize the Guard this summer in California, appeared to be the same one he used for Oregon? She seemed skeptical when Trump’s attorneys citing the president’s Truth Social post as evidence, OPB reported
“Really? A social media post is going to count as a presidential determination that you can send the National Guard to cities? That’s really what I should be relying on?” Immergut said.

Trump directed Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth last week to “provide all necessary troops to protect War-ravaged Portland, and any of our ICR facilities under siege from attack by Antifa, and other domestic terrorists.”
Justice department attorneys said they would immediately appeal Immergut’s ruling to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Trump’s effort to send National Guard soldiers to Portland is a historic moment marking the first time an American president has ever done so, in the city’s 174-year history.
Portland Mayor Keith Wilson and other elected officials responded last week with a news conference to defuse the crisis. “It’s the ‘Don’t take the bait’ press conference,” said U.S. Sen. Jeff Merkley, D-Ore. “Trump has one goal… to make Portland look like what he’s been describing it as. Let’s not grant him that wish.”
How will Oregon guardsmen react?
If Trump succeeds in taking control of the Oregon National Guard: How will Guard members, many of whom have civilian lives in Portland, respond to orders to militarily act against their own city?
“If I were still in the National Guard, I’d reluctantly do a deployment to Portland because the consequences of not reporting for duty are too severe,” said Dylan Serkin, a former guard sergeant who served for six years. “Guardsmen are taught in basic training that they can refuse an order they believe to be illegal, but the burden of proof is on them, and they can be dishonorably discharged or sent to jail.”
Serkin’s unit, the 141st Brigade Support Battalion, currently includes operations at the guard facility in the Portsmouth neighborhood on North Chautauqua Boulevard.
Serkin described Oregon guardsmen as split about 50-50 between liberal and conservative viewpoints, and almost all welcoming non-military assignments such as responding to forest fires and floods, but virtually all reluctant to act as political pawns. If I had to guess from the conservative guardsmen that I know, many of the red state guardsmen recently sent to police Washington, D.C., were saying to themselves, ‘what are we doing here? This is a bull s…t deployment.”
Serkin predicts that many Oregon guardsmen will react that way if deployed to Portland. Former Oregon National Guardsman Jesse Cornett agrees.
“I think that most Oregon guardsmen deployed to Portland would do the bare minimum of tasks, and that’s why I think that Trump would instead send red state units to Portland,” said Cornett, a field artillery specialist often assigned to the guard’s Jackson Armory at 6255 NE Cornfoot Rd., north of the Cully neighborhood.
The Washington Post reported that after Trump sent National Guard troops to Washington, D.C. in August to fight a perceived crime wave, tourism dropped and frightened local residents stayed away from the city’s restaurants and shops, harming the local economy.
Such a scenario alarmed the influential, 2,200-member Portland Metro Chamber business group that’s working with elected officials to oppose Trump’s sending troops to Portland. “Even the Republicans on our board are against this because of the potential for violence and property damage, similar to the summer 2020 protests over the death of George Floyd,” said one person close to Metro Chamber operations.
Most of the 2020 protests were peaceful, but a minority of rioters regularly broke storefront windows and some tried to burn down the Portland Policeman’s Association office at 1868 N. Lombard St.
And it might defuse tensions if protesters sense that many of the guardsmen don’t want to be there either. “Like many jobs,” Serkin said, “guardsmen know how to just do enough work tasks to avoid getting into trouble with their superiors.”

